05 · The Ledger
The bank shut its window before the books were open
Nvidia financed much of the AI boom. Now its interim chief is expected to rein that in, days before Anthropic is due to list. The bulls see a tithe, the bears a burst bubble. Neither has the ledger yet.
Collected from Gary Marcus, Marcus on AI, “Game over, man?,” sent 16 November 2026 at 16:29 UTC (03:29 Tuesday, Melbourne time), read in full; Azeem Azhar, Exponential View, “What Anthropic is really listing,” sent 16:36 UTC, a members’ sketch of which only the opening was in the email; and Alberto Romero, The Algorithmic Bridge, “How NVIDIA’s Crisis Could End the AI Industry as We Know It,” sent 18:42 UTC, of which only the opening and the five section headings were in the email. Quotations from Ben Thompson, the Wall Street Journal and Dave Troy are as Marcus quotes them.
Gary Marcus calls it plainly: game over for the current AI bubble. His evidence is a market, a headline and a quote. Oracle, he writes, is down around 61 per cent since he called its OpenAI deal “peak bubble” last September. Tech stocks kept falling on Monday after last week’s rout. Ben Thompson of Stratechery, as Marcus quotes him, has written an obituary: the demise of Jensen Huang “was the end of a great many things, including Nvidia’s long-term prospects, the AI bubble, and the exceptional way in which the U.S. viewed itself in the world.”
The sharper point is about money. Marcus quotes a Wall Street Journal headline: “Nvidia’s Days as an Open Checkbook for the AI Economy Are Numbered,” with interim chief executive Colette Kress expected to rein in deals after a stretch in which Nvidia aggressively financed computing deals and startup investments. Alberto Romero, in The Algorithmic Bridge, lists “the end of the Bank of Nvidia” among five ways the crisis could reshape the industry. He labels the whole exercise informed speculation, a developing story, to be taken with a grain of salt. The rest of his argument was not in the email we received.
“With all the circular financing, it was always hard to tell what was really happening.” Gary Marcus
That line is the one to keep. When the supplier is also the lender, the sales and the loans are hard to tell apart. Marcus says he has argued since 2023 that the model makers lack a technical moat and struggle to be profitable; he also mentions unspecified “hints” of funny business in Asia, which we cannot weigh because he gives no detail.
Into this walks Anthropic. Marcus says its IPO is planned for Thursday. Azeem Azhar, in a sketch for Exponential View members, calls it the first real AI company in the West to list on a public market, and argues the bear case misses the point: most value in the S&P 500 now sits in intangibles, so Anthropic’s machine intelligence lets it compete for 92 per cent of that value “before it needs to deploy a single robot.” AI companies, he suggests, might extract a permanent tithe on the economy. He presents these as raw notes, his own words, and the full sketch is for paying members; we read only the opening. So on the eve of the listing the two loudest readings are a tithe and a burst bubble. Both are confident. The working, this time, will be in the filing and the first quarters of public numbers. Read those.