03 · Editor’s Letter
They ranked AI by the crowd. The money kept its own list.
For six editions, a16z’s list of the top consumer AI apps was a list of where people went. The seventh, published this week, also asks where people paid, using card-spend data. The two lists barely agree. Of the 50 products ranked by spend, 29 appear on neither traffic chart. Replit is 48th on the web by visits and sixth by revenue. Midjourney has fallen off the traffic list entirely and sits eleventh by money.
That is the Saturday lesson, and it travels. A leaderboard is an argument about what counts, made before anyone looks at the results. Count visits and you get a popularity contest. Count spend and you find a small, intense group paying a median user’s bill thirty-six times over. Count successful pilots and you find most projects never had a number to beat. Count signed data-centre contracts and you get one forecast; count the electricians and you get half of it.
None of the letters below says the crowd is wrong. They say the crowd is one list, and the decisions that matter, what to build, what to price, what to buy, keep getting made off the wrong one. Pick the list before you read the ranking.
Skip cover